Do you think Kurt Cobain changed music?

Live Poll

Do you think Kurt Cobain changed music?

View Results
  • 37026
    Yes, his influence won't be forgotten.
    64%
  • 37027
    Maybe, but he was part of a group of musicians that changed the scene.
    18%
  • 37028
    No, Cobain was totally overrated.
    19%

VoteTotal Votes: 1910

Results with 35 short comments
Total of 1,910 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

63.6%
Yes, his influence won't be forgotten.
1,214 votes
17.6%
Maybe, but he was part of a group of musicians that changed the scene.
336 votes
18.8%
No, Cobain was totally overrated.
360 votes
Display Comments:
No, Cobain was totally overrated.

The changes that the music world credits to him were happening anyway. Pearl Jam and other bands were already moving us away from big hair.

  • 1 vote
 - 8:17 pm EDT on Tue Mar 31, 2009
No, Cobain was totally overrated.

He might have had a chance to mature as a musician, kick drugs and do some great work. However, he was murdered by that hole Courtney Love.

  • 2 votes
 - 10:21 pm EDT on Tue Mar 31, 2009
No, Cobain was totally overrated.

He changed music, for the worse. PS He wanted to be in Cheap Trick.

  • 1 vote
 - 8:39 am EDT on Wed Apr 1, 2009
Yes, his influence won't be forgotten.

Absolutely.

     - 8:45 am EDT on Wed Apr 1, 2009
    Yes, his influence won't be forgotten.

    Every couple of decades, an artist will come along who can actually deliver "3 chords and the truth" - Kurt did that and we listened...

       - 11:34 am EDT on Wed Apr 1, 2009
      No, Cobain was totally overrated.

      Changed it yes, but change is not always better

      • 1 vote
       - 2:30 pm EDT on Wed Apr 1, 2009
      No, Cobain was totally overrated.

      Dude was totally overrated. Some dumb ingrate kid whining about his charmed life isn't change.

      • 1 vote
       - Hot-Dog
       - 2:31 pm EDT on Wed Apr 1, 2009
      No, Cobain was totally overrated.

      Ask any people who Kurt Cobain is and most will say I have no idea.

      • 2 votes
       - Budship
       - 2:37 pm EDT on Wed Apr 1, 2009
      Yes, his influence won't be forgotten.

      To his generation, yes. To anyone who wasn't "of age" in his prime, no... which works out just fine for those in the know.

         - 3:23 pm EDT on Wed Apr 1, 2009
        Yes, his influence won't be forgotten.

        Absolutely. Cobain was the creative force behind Nirvana, and Nirvana brought "alternative" rock into the mainstream.

           - Shaq
           - 4:11 pm EDT on Wed Apr 1, 2009
          No, Cobain was totally overrated.

          Always felt he was overated...I know Cobain was the voice of his generation blah, blah but he was actually better songwriter than musician

          • 1 vote
           - 4:15 pm EDT on Wed Apr 1, 2009
          Maybe, but he was part of a group of musicians that changed the scene.

          Sure he's influential, but dying early means you don't have to face critics over a longer span. Eddie Vedder hasn't been relevent since VS

          • 1 vote
           - skitch
           - 4:15 pm EDT on Wed Apr 1, 2009
          Yes, his influence won't be forgotten.

          Being in my 50s, I can honestly think of only one other musician who gave us comparable gifts to what Kurt gave, that being John Lennon.

          • 2 votes
           - DMCinLV
           - 7:27 pm EDT on Wed Apr 1, 2009
          No, Cobain was totally overrated.

          Lyrical ingenuity of an 8th grade creative writing class (Serve the Servents, Scentless Apprentice, it's a crime when I rhyme all the time.

          • 1 vote
           - 9:11 pm EDT on Wed Apr 1, 2009
          Yes, his influence won't be forgotten.

          Where theres a shift, theres a change...he was part of that shift, he's part of the change. to non believers...listen again...

             - 10:59 pm EDT on Wed Apr 1, 2009
            Maybe, but he was part of a group of musicians that changed the scene.

            More for his death and his poetry than as a "musician". If he saw further is was because "he stood on the shoulders of giants."

               - 11:59 am EDT on Fri Apr 3, 2009
              No, Cobain was totally overrated.

              Mudhoney! Screaming Trees! Soundgarden! AIC! I miss Layne Staley.

                 - 12:02 pm EDT on Fri Apr 3, 2009
                Maybe, but he was part of a group of musicians that changed the scene.

                if he did, why does so much of today's music suck? crap lyrics, no melodies, zero talent. btw, louder doesn't mean better!

                • 1 vote
                 - 1:41 pm EDT on Sat Apr 4, 2009
                Yes, his influence won't be forgotten.

                Only few artists come along in a lifetime that change the music scene. Kurt and Nirvana were one of them.

                   - 10:49 pm EDT on Sat Apr 4, 2009
                  No, Cobain was totally overrated.

                  Cobain played punk-which was nothing new. Nirvana was just marketed very well-and people bought it. In Utero was the only good album.

                  • 2 votes
                   - 11:12 pm EDT on Sat Apr 4, 2009
                  Maybe, but he was part of a group of musicians that changed the scene.

                  Undoubtedly, Kurt DID change music. From the "grunge" era, though, I MUCH prefer Soundgarden.

                     - Jon G
                     - 2:32 am EDT on Mon Apr 6, 2009
                    Yes, his influence won't be forgotten.

                    Yes. Absolutely. Had he lived longer, as with every other artist, the music would become better. We just didn't get the chance to hear it.

                       - 12:14 pm EDT on Mon Apr 6, 2009
                      Yes, his influence won't be forgotten.

                      Listen to Kurt and Nirvana. His lyrics and style changed music and he will go down in music history.

                         - 12:51 pm EDT on Mon Apr 6, 2009
                        Yes, his influence won't be forgotten.

                        Kurt was gifted beyond anyone else in a very gifted Seattle scene. Grunge brought back rock and Kurt led the charge.

                           - 1:33 pm EDT on Mon Apr 6, 2009
                          Maybe, but he was part of a group of musicians that changed the scene.

                          The fact that it's still even being debated 15 years later should be answer enough.

                             - 2:30 pm EDT on Mon Apr 6, 2009

                            This discussion is closed.

                            Discuss this post